loyaltyretail strategycustomer retention

Loyalty & Jewellery: What Retailers Can Learn from Frasers' Membership Merge

UUnknown

2026-02-27

9 min read

Discover how Frasers' loyalty merge can reshape jewellery loyalty: tiered perks, partner rewards and experiential benefits to boost retention.

Why your jewellery store can't ignore the Frasers Plus playbook

Retention is the single most reliable lever for jewellery retailers — yet many brands still treat loyalty as an afterthought. If you worry about customers not returning, unsure how to reward high-value buyers, or struggle to connect in-store experiences with online sales, Frasers Group's 2026 integration of Sports Direct membership into Frasers Plus holds lessons you can apply right away.

Quick context: what Frasers did and why it matters now

In early 2026 Frasers Group unified separate loyalty schemes — most notably Sports Direct membership — into one platform, Frasers Plus. The move simplified membership tiers, broadened cross-brand benefits and centred on a single customer identity across more than 300 stores and digital channels. Retail commentators framed this as a strategic pivot to increase lifetime value and cut friction in account management. As Retail Gazette noted, Frasers is creating a unified rewards platform to better serve customers across its portfolio.

“Frasers Group integrates Sports Direct membership into Frasers Plus to create one unified, rewards platform.” — Retail Gazette, 2026

This shift isn't just corporate housekeeping. It's a response to three 2026 retail realities: stronger demand for frictionless omnichannel experiences, the emergence of privacy-first first-party data strategies, and customers valuing experiential rewards more than ever. Jewellery retailers that borrow the right elements from this playbook can dramatically improve customer retention and profitability.

How jewellery retail differs — and what that means for membership strategy

Jewellery is purchase-driven by emotion, trust and fit. Buyers need assurance on authenticity and certification, reassurance about sizing and repairs, and inspiration for styling. Unlike fast-moving sport or fashion goods, jewellery purchases are higher value and lower frequency, which changes loyalty economics:

High average order value (AOV) but fewer repeat transactions per year
Stronger need for post-purchase services (resizing, warranty, insurance)
Emotional drivers (celebrations, engagements) that reward experiential perks

Consequently, a jewellery-specific loyalty programme needs to prioritise service, trust and meaningful experiences over purely transactional discounts.

Three pillars jewellery retailers should adopt from Frasers Plus

Frasers' integration emphasised unity across brands, clearer tiering, and cross-brand benefits. Translate these into jewellery retail and you get three actionable pillars:

1. Tiered perks tied to lifetime value and milestones

Tiering creates aspiration and predictable progression. But jewellery tiering must reflect buying behaviour — it should reward not only spend but loyalty actions relevant to high-value purchase cycles.

Example tiers: Silver (entry), Gold (repeat buyers and referrals), Platinum (high lifetime spend or multiple key events), Bespoke (VIP clients / collectors)
Perks to include: free resizing credits, priority ring-sizing appointments, extended warranties, annual jewellery health check, dedicated concierge for bespoke commissions
Milestone triggers: first anniversary of purchase, engagement purchase to wedding completion, three-year collector threshold — these unlock experiential rewards

Practical setup: map spend thresholds to realistic margins. If average first-purchase AOV is £400 and your margin supports a 5% long-term reward, construct tiers so the economics scale with lifetime value.

2. Cross-brand and partner rewards that increase relevance

Frasers maximised the value of a unified audience by enabling members to redeem points across diverse brands. Jewellery retailers can replicate this by forming curated partnerships that enhance the lifestyle appeal of jewellery purchases.

In-store partners: watchmakers, designer boutiques, tailoring services — share joint perks like styling appointments or co-hosted trunk shows
Service partners: insurers (first-year jewellery insurance discounts), local restaurants (dinner vouchers for anniversary shoppers), photography studios (complimentary photos for engagement/wedding buys)
Cross-category ecommerce: allow points to be redeemed for gift-wrap, engraved monograms or expedited engraving services

Cross-brand rewards increase the utility of a single account and bring lifestyle relevance that extends beyond the transaction.

3. Experiential rewards that drive emotional loyalty

Experiences move the needle in jewellery. Customers remember a private viewing or a bespoke design session far longer than a coupon.

Private after-hours showings with gemologists
Exclusive workshops: design your own ring, birthstone education evenings
VIP access to seasonal collections and pre-sales
Concierge services for anniversaries, gifting and warranty handling

These perks differentiate a jewellery loyalty programme from commodity-based retail clubs.

Features to implement now: practical checklist for jewellery retailers

Below are concrete features and the steps to implement them. Treat this as a pragmatic roadmap you can pilot within 90 days.

Tier mechanics and perks

Define tier criteria: combine lifetime spend and behavioural triggers (e.g., referrals, product reviews, event attendance)
Automate upgrades/downgrades through CRM to avoid manual errors
Offer immediate, visible perks (e.g., free resizing voucher) and aspirational perks (e.g., bespoke design session)

Cross-brand integrations

List 5 potential partners with aligned customer bases
Negotiate reciprocal benefits and simple redemption flows
Integrate partner redemptions into your member dashboard

Experiential programmes

Launch a monthly VIP event for Gold+ tiers
Promote workshops that double as social content opportunities
Use these events to collect zero-party data (style preferences, gifting plans)

Service-based perks

Include complimentary first-year insurance or discounted renewals
Offer free lifetime polishing or a fixed number of complimentary repairs
Bundle certificate storage and digital provenance with higher tiers

Digital-first features

Member dashboard with unified points balance and order history
AR virtual try-on integrated with loyalty (unlock premium filters for Gold+)
Seamless omnichannel redemption at POS and online

CRM, data and tech: the backbone of a modern membership

Loyalty is only as good as the data that powers it. Post-2025 privacy shifts and the cookieless landscape mean first-party data and CRM orchestration are non-negotiable.

Practical tech stack:

CRM: Salesforce, Shopify Plus + native CRM, or Klaviyo for SMBs
Loyalty engine: LoyaltyLion, Smile.io, Annex Cloud or a bespoke module tied to your CRM
POS integration: ensure real-time syncing for points and redemptions
Marketing automation: lifecycle flows for onboarding, anniversaries, win-backs and loyalty nudges
Analytics: single customer view and LTV modelling tools

Tip: build a lightweight pilot using a CRM + loyalty plugin before committing to a full rebuild. Capture the most valuable KPIs immediately:

Repeat purchase rate
Customer lifetime value (CLTV)
Redemption rate and average redemption value
Retention rate by tier

Designing a launch plan: 90-day pilot to scale

Follow a three-phase playbook to minimise risk and prove impact.

Phase 1 — Define (Weeks 1–2)

Segment your top 20% of customers — examine AOV, recency and frequency
Choose 2–3 aspirational perks and 3 practical perks for the MVP
Map data flows between CRM, POS and loyalty engine

Phase 2 — Pilot (Weeks 3–10)

Invite top customers to an exclusive pilot (create scarcity)
Run one VIP event and one cross-brand redemption pilot
Track engagement, NPS, redemption and repeat orders

Phase 3 — Iterate & Scale (Weeks 11–12+)

Refine perks and thresholds using pilot data
Expand to wider audience in waves to control capacity for events and services
Invest in staff training — ambassadors should understand tiers and service commitments

Metrics and targets: what success looks like

Set measurable goals from day one. Benchmarks for a successful jewellery loyalty scheme in year one:

Increase in repeat purchase rate: +15–30% among members
Lift in CLTV: +20% for members vs non-members
Redemption rate: 25–40% for points-based perks (higher for experiential rewards)
Event NPS: target 60+ for VIP experiences

These are directional targets — adjust based on your baseline and margins.

Customer privacy and trust — essential in 2026

Today’s consumers expect transparency. Loyalty programmes must earn the right to collect deeper personal data (gift dates, ring size, style preferences) by providing clear value in return.

Implement clear consent flows and simple data controls in the member dashboard
Offer value exchange: exclusive pre-sale access for customers who share gifting dates
Store certificates, provenance and service history in a secure digital vault

Trust equals retention. If a customer believes you protect their purchase and personalisation data, they are more likely to invest in higher value items.

How to avoid common pitfalls

We’ve seen many retailers try loyalty and fail. Here are the typical mistakes and how to avoid them:

Pitfall: Too many discounts that erode margin. Fix: emphasise experiential and service-led benefits.
Pitfall: Overcomplicated tiers. Fix: simple thresholds and clear communication.
Pitfall: No omnichannel integration. Fix: ensure POS and ecommerce share a single points ledger.
Pitfall: Ignoring staff enablement. Fix: train store ambassadors as loyalty coaches.

Examples that work — mini case studies

Below are anonymised examples based on retailer pilots in late 2025–early 2026.

Case A — Independent boutique (London)

Launched a Gold tier at £2,000 lifetime spend. Benefits included one free resizing, earlier access to bespoke commissions and a yearly polish. Within 9 months the boutique saw a 28% uplift in repeat purchases and a 23% increase in average order value for Gold members.

Case B — Regional chain

Partnered with a local photographer and high-end restaurant to create a cross-brand redemption path. Members could redeem points for a couple’s photoshoot. The partnership increased sign-ups by 40% during the first quarter and drove footfall during slow seasons.

Case C — National retailer

Launched private gemologist consultations for Platinum clients, combined with a digital certificate vault. Member retention improved by 18% and survey scores on trust increased significantly.

Final takeaways — build loyalty that fits jewellery

Frasers Plus shows the power of a unified programme. For jewellery retailers the lesson is clear: combine tiered perks, cross-brand rewards and experiential services to drive emotional loyalty and long-term value.

Start small, measure relentlessly and scale the experiences that increase CLTV most efficiently. Prioritise trust-building benefits (certificates, warranties, insurance), design aspirational tiers and integrate partners to widen the programme’s appeal.

Next steps — a 5-point action plan you can use this week

Audit your top 20% customers and identify 3 behaviour triggers to reward.
Design two tiers with clear perks: one practical (resizing, polish), one experiential (private viewing, workshop).
Choose one partner (photographer, restaurant or insurer) and negotiate a pilot cross-redemption.
Run a 90-day pilot with a CRM + loyalty plugin and track repeat rate and redemption.
Train staff on membership benefits and launch a VIP event to convert early advocates.

Ready to build a jewellery loyalty programme that lasts?

If you want a checklist, ROI model or pilot blueprint tailored to your store size and margin profile, request our membership playbook. We’ve distilled the Frasers Plus lessons into a jewellery-first framework with templates for tiers, email flows and event scripts — tested in late 2025 and updated for 2026 privacy and AI trends.

Act now: A well-designed membership programme can lift repeat purchase rates, increase CLTV and create lifelong customers. Contact us to get the playbook and plan a 90-day pilot.

Unknown

Contributor

Senior editor and content strategist. Writing about technology, design, and the future of digital media. Follow along for deep dives into the industry's moving parts.